Contrasting Views on Royalty Payment
For the same royalty payment, if the tax authority views it as ‘irrelevant to imported goods’ while the customs authority sees it as ‘related to imported goods’, importers may feel embarrassed. However, importers should keep it in mind that customs duties and internal taxes are levied under separate laws with different tax purposes, taxable objects, tax bases, and tax calculation methods. Viewing the imposition of internal taxes according to internal tax laws as affecting the imposition of customs duties or as double taxation is not accurate. Below is the summary of a tax tribunal appeal case (Case No. 조심 2022 관 0142 ). Exporter A sold Product A, which carried a trademark, to a Korean importer, Company A. Company A paid only the price of Product A to Exporter A. Subsequently, Exporter A and Company A jointly invested and established Company B in Korea. Exporter A then sold the same Product A to Company B, requiring Company B to pay both the Product A price and a royal...